Editorial scope: Entries are structured allegations and research questions, not adjudicated facts. The site separates direct textual tensions from archaeology, genetics, translation history, later LDS doctrine, and nineteenth-century-authorship arguments. Common Latter-day Saint responses are shown alongside the criticism, and weaker or outdated allegations are labeled accordingly.
0Visible issues
0Book of Mormon references
0Books represented
0Research sources
0Active categories
Book of Mormon · 15 books

Issue connections across the text

Each Book of Mormon book occupies an equal-width segment. Arcs connect the first references on each side of an issue; single-passage issues appear as short local arcs. The visualization shows relationships, not proof counts.

Structured issue records

Issues

Editorial framework

How MormonAudit handles Book of Mormon claims

The Book of Mormon makes several different kinds of claims: internal narrative claims, historical and archaeological claims, supernatural claims, translation-history claims, and theological claims. MormonAudit keeps those categories distinct before evaluating them.

Primary text first

Every record links back to the official Book of Mormon text before presenting criticism or defense.

Contradiction test

Before labeling a contradiction, compare subject, chronology, scope, speaker, conditions, translation wording, and whether one passage explicitly qualifies another.

Anachronism test

Material-culture allegations distinguish absence of evidence from positive contradiction, and weaker/outdated claims such as “coinage” or cement are flagged.

Interpretive dependence

Low marks direct textual or chronological conflict; moderate marks issues affected by translation/geography/context; high marks arguments that depend heavily on external evidence, authorship theory, or supernatural assumptions.

Common responses

Each issue gives a concise Latter-day Saint response for inspection rather than presuming it succeeds.

Relational analysis

The optional relational block distinguishes internal contradiction from external historical criticism, textual dependence, translation-history questions, and comparisons with later LDS doctrine.

Research provenance

Source library

The initial build uses the official Book of Mormon text, Joseph Smith Papers’ 1830 edition, MormonThink’s critical issue index, official Church essays on translation and DNA, and BYU Religious Studies Center / ScholarsArchive material for LDS scholarly responses to anachronisms, Isaiah, KJV language, and genetics.